| Mangiapane Potential Trade [message #849438] |
Fri, 09 January 2026 11:20  |
 |
 HamBlaster
Messages: 1309
Registered: June 2007
1 Cup
|
|
I'm sure we've all read the reports of Mangiapane wanting out, and the potential targets discussed so far of Strome and Reilly.
What are people's thoughts on them?
I think Strome is an absolute no go. 6 points in 23 games is at best a lateral move, however Mangiapane has been the better player (imo) over his career. I don't see a soft Ryan Strome being an upgrade on a guy that can be a great pest (if he finds his game again).
Reilly could be a really nice addition though; shores up the second pairing and gives the Oil an alternative to Ekholm that they could run on the top pairing if he continues to struggle with the pace of the game (Ek's game has stabilized, however I think he's obviously lost a step). I can't see why or how Toronto thinks this is a good idea, however there's been smoke around this... so maybe? Treliving is not a great GM.
Apparently Edmonton has spoken with Detroit, Vancouver and Winnipeg as well. I'm assuming Sherwood out of Vancouver, however who do you think they'd be looking at with the other two squads?
The Oilers need a personality, and their acquisitions of Frederic and Mangiapane were probably intended to be the replacements of Kane and Perry... and so far, we've seen a whimper from both. Freddy lit a fire under the guys when he took on Stanley in that last Jets game (even though the turtle at the end was pretty embarrassing), so that was a start... but this team needs jam and some disturbers. We don't have much of anything resembling that right now.
[Updated on: Fri, 09 January 2026 11:24]
|
|
|
|
 |
NZ Oiler Fan
Messages: 1510
Registered: October 2006
Location: Summerside, PEI
1 Cup
|
|
| HamBlaster wrote on Fri, 09 January 2026 14:20 |
I'm sure we've all read the reports of Mangiapane wanting out, and the potential targets discussed so far of Strome and Reilly.
What are people's thoughts on them?
I think Strome is an absolute no go. 6 points in 23 games is at best a lateral move, however Mangiapane has been the better player (imo) over his career. I don't see a soft Ryan Strome being an upgrade on a guy that can be a great pest (if he finds his game again).
Reilly could be a really nice addition though; shores up the second pairing and gives the Oil an alternative to Ekholm that they could run on the top pairing if he continues to struggle with the pace of the game (Ek's game has stabilized, however I think he's obviously lost a step). I can't see why or how Toronto thinks this is a good idea, however there's been smoke around this... so maybe? Treliving is not a great GM.
Apparently Edmonton has spoken with Detroit, Vancouver and Winnipeg as well. I'm assuming Sherwood out of Vancouver, however who do you think they'd be looking at with the other two squads?
The Oilers need a personality, and their acquisitions of Frederic and Mangiapane were probably intended to be the replacements of Kane and Perry... and so far, we've seen a whimper from both. Freddy lit a fire under the guys when he took on Stanley in that last Jets game (even though the turtle at the end was pretty embarrassing), so that was a start... but this team needs jam and some disturbers. We don't have much of anything resembling that right now.
|
Reilly carries a $7.5m cap hit doesn't he? I wouldn't think that the cap would work on him. No interest in Strome either.
|
|
|
|
 |
Kr55
Messages: 12339
Registered: May 2002
Location: Edmonton
6 Cups
|
|
| NZ Oiler Fan wrote on Fri, 09 January 2026 11:42 |
| HamBlaster wrote on Fri, 09 January 2026 14:20 |
I'm sure we've all read the reports of Mangiapane wanting out, and the potential targets discussed so far of Strome and Reilly.
What are people's thoughts on them?
I think Strome is an absolute no go. 6 points in 23 games is at best a lateral move, however Mangiapane has been the better player (imo) over his career. I don't see a soft Ryan Strome being an upgrade on a guy that can be a great pest (if he finds his game again).
Reilly could be a really nice addition though; shores up the second pairing and gives the Oil an alternative to Ekholm that they could run on the top pairing if he continues to struggle with the pace of the game (Ek's game has stabilized, however I think he's obviously lost a step). I can't see why or how Toronto thinks this is a good idea, however there's been smoke around this... so maybe? Treliving is not a great GM.
Apparently Edmonton has spoken with Detroit, Vancouver and Winnipeg as well. I'm assuming Sherwood out of Vancouver, however who do you think they'd be looking at with the other two squads?
The Oilers need a personality, and their acquisitions of Frederic and Mangiapane were probably intended to be the replacements of Kane and Perry... and so far, we've seen a whimper from both. Freddy lit a fire under the guys when he took on Stanley in that last Jets game (even though the turtle at the end was pretty embarrassing), so that was a start... but this team needs jam and some disturbers. We don't have much of anything resembling that right now.
|
Reilly carries a $7.5m cap hit doesn't he? I wouldn't think that the cap would work on him. No interest in Strome either.
|
Yikes, Ryan Strome at 5M with another year left. That's 1.4M more cap hit than the Mange for even less performance.
Can we do Rielly for Nurse straight up? :)
"We need to get better immediately. That starts today"
- Lowe, 2013
"Next year I would forecast as another developmental year"
- MacT, 2015
5 x $5,000,000
|
|
|
|
 |
Mike
Messages: 1945
Registered: August 2005
Location: Moncton, New Brunswick
1 Cup
|
|
| Kr55 wrote on Fri, 09 January 2026 15:18 |
Can we do Rielly for Nurse straight up? :)
|
I’ll build Bowman a statue myself!
|
|
|
|
